Choosing between Secrets Papagayo Costa Rica and Andaz Costa Rica Resort at Peninsula Papagayo? This comparison highlights adults-only all-inclusive luxury versus contemporary design-forward resort amenities, covering location, rooms, dining, beach experiences, and overall value to help you decide your ideal Costa Rica getaway.
Resort comparison guide
Secrets Papagayo Costa Rica vs Andaz Costa Rica Resort
Secrets Papagayo Costa Rica
Adults-Only • All-Inclusive • Unlimited-Luxury®
Best for couples and adults who want a seamless adults-only all-inclusive experience on Peninsula Papagayo with the Unlimited-Luxury® concept, stunning Pacific views, and easy access to Costa Rica adventures.
Andaz Costa Rica Resort at Peninsula Papagayo
Boutique Luxury • Hyatt • Design-Forward
Better for travelers who want a design-forward boutique luxury experience with treehouse-inspired architecture, à la carte dining, and a more curated, Hyatt-brand resort atmosphere.
Quick Verdict: Secrets Papagayo vs Andaz Costa Rica
If you want a seamless adults-only all-inclusive where everything is included—dining, drinks, activities, and gratuities—Secrets Papagayo Costa Rica is typically the better pick, especially for couples who value convenience, Unlimited-Luxury® perks, and a romantic beachfront setting.
If your priority is a design-forward boutique luxury experience with more à la carte flexibility and a unique architectural style, Andaz Costa Rica Resort usually comes out ahead—particularly for travelers who want Hyatt points benefits, treehouse-inspired design, and a curated resort feel.
Bottom line: choose Secrets Papagayo for stress-free all-inclusive romance and value, and choose Andaz for a boutique luxury escape with more design personality and à la carte dining freedom.
Secrets Papagayo vs Andaz Costa Rica – At a Glance
| Category | Secrets Papagayo Costa Rica | Andaz Costa Rica Resort |
|---|---|---|
| Overall Vibe |
Romantic adults-only all-inclusive with Unlimited-Luxury® inclusions, Pacific Ocean views, and a relaxed tropical atmosphere on Peninsula Papagayo.
Best for All-Inclusive
|
Design-forward boutique luxury resort with treehouse-inspired architecture, à la carte dining, and a curated Hyatt experience.
Best for Design Lovers
|
| Location | On Peninsula Papagayo's Arenilla Beach in Guanacaste, with easy access to nature excursions, zip-lining, and Costa Rica's Pacific coastline. | Also on Peninsula Papagayo, nestled into the hillside rainforest with stunning bay views and proximity to multiple beaches within the peninsula. |
| Rooms & Suites | Spacious suites with ocean or tropical views, private balconies, and Unlimited-Luxury® amenities like 24-hour room service and stocked mini-bars. | Treehouse-inspired suites and rooms with contemporary Costa Rican design, some with plunge pools, and a more boutique, architectural feel. |
| Dining | Multiple à la carte restaurants included with no reservations required, plus 24-hour dining options and premium drinks at all bars. | Curated à la carte restaurants (not included in room rate), farm-to-table focus, and a more foodie-forward culinary philosophy. |
| Pools & Beach | Stunning infinity pools overlooking the Pacific, plus direct beach access to Arenilla Beach with calm waters and loungers included. | Multiple tiered infinity pools integrated into the hillside design, with beach club access and a more spread-out, exploratory layout. |
| Activities & Spa | Included activities like kayaking, snorkeling, and fitness classes, plus the Secrets Spa by Pevonia® with hydrotherapy (spa treatments extra). | On-site adventures and excursions available (often at extra cost), plus a full-service spa with local-inspired treatments. |
| Price & Value | Best value if you want everything included—meals, drinks, tips, activities—with no surprise charges at checkout. | Best value for Hyatt loyalists earning/redeeming points, or travelers who prefer à la carte flexibility over all-inclusive bundling. |
Rooms & Suites: All-Inclusive Comfort vs Boutique Design
Secrets Papagayo – Room Style
Rooms and suites at Secrets Papagayo Costa Rica are spacious, romantic, and designed for couples who want ocean or tropical views, private balconies, and all the Unlimited-Luxury® perks built in.
- Junior suites to master suites with varying views and sizes
- 24-hour room service, stocked mini-bar, and Unlimited-Luxury® amenities included
- Best for couples who want seamless comfort without tracking expenses
Secrets is the better pick if you want a straightforward, all-inclusive suite experience where everything is covered from check-in to checkout.
Andaz Costa Rica – Room Style
Andaz Costa Rica Resort delivers a design-forward boutique experience with treehouse-inspired suites, contemporary Costa Rican aesthetics, and a more architectural approach to guest rooms.
- Unique treehouse-style rooms with floor-to-ceiling windows and forest/ocean views
- Select suites feature private plunge pools
- Best for travelers who value design, aesthetics, and a curated boutique feel
If you want rooms that feel like a design magazine spread with a more intimate, boutique atmosphere, Andaz is usually the stronger fit.
Dining & Drinks: All-Inclusive Variety vs À La Carte Excellence
Secrets Papagayo – Restaurants & Bars
Dining at Secrets Papagayo Costa Rica follows the Unlimited-Luxury® model—multiple à la carte restaurants, no reservations required, and premium drinks included at all bars.
Expect:
- Multiple specialty restaurants: seafood, Asian, Mexican, Mediterranean, and more
- 24-hour dining options including room service
- All drinks, including top-shelf spirits and wine, included
Andaz Costa Rica – Restaurants & Bars
Andaz Costa Rica Resort takes a curated à la carte approach with farm-to-table dining, locally-inspired menus, and a more foodie-forward philosophy—dining is not included in the room rate.
- Multiple restaurants with Costa Rican and international cuisines
- Farm-to-table focus with local ingredients and craft cocktails
- Best for travelers who want culinary exploration and are okay paying à la carte
If you're a foodie who values quality over quantity and doesn't mind à la carte pricing, Andaz typically delivers a more elevated culinary experience.
Pools & Beach: Beachfront Infinity vs Hillside Tiers
Secrets Papagayo – Pool & Beach Scene
Secrets Papagayo Costa Rica features stunning infinity pools with Pacific Ocean views and direct access to Arenilla Beach—a calm, swimmable shoreline perfect for couples.
- Main infinity pool overlooking Culebra Bay
- Direct beach access with loungers, umbrellas, and waiter service included
- Best for couples who want a classic beachfront all-inclusive pool experience
Andaz Costa Rica – Pool & Beach Scene
Andaz Costa Rica Resort offers tiered infinity pools integrated into the hillside with a more spread-out, exploratory layout and beach club access to nearby Peninsula Papagayo beaches.
- Multiple infinity pools at different levels with forest and bay views
- Beach club access (short shuttle or walk to beaches)
- Better for travelers who want design-integrated pools and a more exploratory beach setup
If you want pools that feel like part of the architecture with a more adventurous beach approach, Andaz delivers a unique layout.
Activities & Spa: Included Adventures vs Curated Experiences
Secrets Papagayo – Activities & Wellness
Activities at Secrets Papagayo Costa Rica are largely included with your stay—kayaking, snorkeling, paddleboarding, fitness classes, and more come with the Unlimited-Luxury® experience.
- Non-motorized water sports included (kayaks, paddleboards, snorkel gear)
- Fitness center, yoga classes, and daily activities programming
- Secrets Spa by Pevonia® with hydrotherapy circuit (treatments extra)
Andaz Costa Rica – Activities & Wellness
Andaz Costa Rica Resort offers curated adventures and excursions—many at additional cost—with a focus on eco-tourism, local experiences, and Peninsula Papagayo exploration.
- On-site excursions like zip-lining, kayaking, and nature tours (often extra)
- Fitness center and complimentary yoga sessions
- Full-service Onda Spa with locally-inspired treatments
If you want more activities included without tracking costs, Secrets is the easier choice. Andaz works better for travelers who prefer à la carte adventure booking.
Price & Value: Which Costa Rica Resort Feels More Worth It?
Secrets Papagayo – Value Snapshot
Secrets Papagayo Costa Rica offers the most value when you want everything bundled into one price—meals, drinks, tips, activities, and 24-hour room service with no surprise charges.
- Best for couples who want stress-free, all-inclusive romance
- Great if you'll use the included dining, drinks, and activities heavily
- Strong "peace of mind" value—no tracking expenses during your trip
Andaz Costa Rica – Value Snapshot
Andaz Costa Rica Resort is the better value if you're a Hyatt loyalist earning or redeeming points, or if you prefer à la carte flexibility over bundled all-inclusive pricing.
- Best for World of Hyatt members maximizing points
- Stronger for travelers who want design and don't need all-inclusive convenience
- Worth it if you value boutique luxury, architecture, and curated dining
Who Wins? Best Costa Rica Resort by Travel Style
Best for Stress-Free Romance
Secrets Papagayo Costa Rica
Choose Secrets if you want all-inclusive simplicity, romantic dining, and a couples-focused atmosphere with no surprise charges.
Best for Design & Architecture Lovers
Andaz Costa Rica Resort
Andaz is the better pick for travelers who want treehouse-inspired design, boutique luxury, and a curated aesthetic experience.
Best for Honeymoons & Anniversaries
Secrets Papagayo Costa Rica
For honeymoons and milestone celebrations, Secrets delivers romantic inclusions, candlelit dinners, and an adults-only atmosphere built for couples.
Best for Hyatt Loyalists & Points Travelers
Andaz Costa Rica Resort
If you're a World of Hyatt member earning or redeeming points, Andaz offers strong loyalty value and a luxury Costa Rica redemption option.
BOOK YOUR STAY NOW
Questions? Contact Us!
- Agents Available 24/7
- Lowest Price Guaranteed
- Complimentary Perks & Upgrades
- Agents Available 24/7
- Lowest Price Guaranteed
- Complimentary Perks & Upgrades
More Secrets Papagayo Costa Rica Comparison Guides
Explore how Secrets Papagayo Costa Rica stacks up against other top all-inclusive resorts in Costa Rica:
- Secrets Papagayo Costa Rica vs Westin Reserva Conchal
- Secrets Papagayo Costa Rica vs W Costa Rica – Reserva Conchal
- Secrets Papagayo Costa Rica vs Tamarindo Diria Beach Resort
- Secrets Papagayo Costa Rica vs Riu Palace Costa Rica
- Secrets Papagayo Costa Rica vs Riu Guanacaste
- Secrets Papagayo Costa Rica vs Planet Hollywood Costa Rica
- Secrets Papagayo Costa Rica vs Occidental Papagayo
- Secrets Papagayo Costa Rica vs Nekajui, a Ritz-Carlton Reserve
- Secrets Papagayo Costa Rica vs Margaritaville Playa Flamingo
- Secrets Papagayo Costa Rica vs Hilton Garden Inn Guanacaste Airport
- Secrets Papagayo Costa Rica vs Hacienda Guachipelin
- Secrets Papagayo Costa Rica vs Four Seasons Peninsula Papagayo
- Secrets Papagayo Costa Rica vs El Mangroove Autograph Collection
- Secrets Papagayo Costa Rica vs Dreams Las Mareas Costa Rica
- Secrets Papagayo Costa Rica vs Casa Chameleon at Las Catalinas
- Secrets Papagayo Costa Rica vs Cala Luna Boutique Hotel & Villas
- Secrets Papagayo Costa Rica vs Bahia del Sol
- Secrets Papagayo Costa Rica vs Andaz Costa Rica Peninsula Papagayo